Chapdelaine – Comparing Inkle and Yarico Texts

Inkle and Yarico is a popular story that circulated across our culture from the late 18th century to well into the 19th century. It describes a colonialist, Inkle; someone who is being colonized (often portrayed as Native American), Yairco; and the love between them. Because it caught the attention of the general public, several new versions were realized during its popularity. One version, A Modern Inkle and Yarico was released in 1841 and describes the colonization of the Red Hills (a region above Florida). I used the web-tools below to perform computational text analysis on this text as well as this text as it relates to Steele’s version to answer the question: How has the different portrayal of gender and race across versions related to the different outcomes?

WordCount

The first tool that I used was WordCount provided by DataBasic.io. This tool allows you to see what are the most frequently used words in a given text are. The results of Steele’s version of the text and A Modern Inkle and Yarico are shown below.

 

Results (truncated):

Unknown’s

A Modern Inkle and Yarico

Steele’s
Inkle and Yarico
Word Frequency
graham 8
white 7
oceola 6
upon 6
yet 6
beauty 6
young 5
indians 5
seminole 5
many 5
warrior 4
whose 4
would 4
form 4
Word Frequency
upon 10
man 7
made 5
women 5
us 5
young 4
story 4
men 4
lion 4
inkle 4
yarico 4
arietta 3
time 3
agreeable 3

Follow these hyperlinks for the full results: Inkle and Yarico and A Modern Inkle and Yarico.

 

Although this way of analyzing a text can be limited, it proves to be a powerful tool to see the focus of each text. For example, whiteis the most common word in A Modern Inkle and Yarico, appearing 8 times. Based on the story, it is a reasonable assumption to say that these references to white are both relating to the race rather than the color and also relates to the Inkle of the story (who is named Graham). Whereas the race of Inkle in Steele’s version is not as apparent (as no words relating to race appear in the top words of the text). Although the clear difference between the two is that in A Modern Inkle and Yarico, graham is the most used word whereas names in Inkle and Yarico aren’t as frequent. This suggests that the former is more personal. Just by this, we can understand why the relationship in A Modern Inkle and Yarico was less transactional and more genuine than the one in Inkle and Yarico.

There are clear similarities of these two texts just by looking at the frequency of the words, however. For example, both texts have the theme of age with young making the top list in both. The theme of gender is also apparent in both texts. In Inkle and Yarico, manand women make the list. The reason that gender isn’t as apparent in A Modern is that these results are ignoring stop words, which include pronouns. Taking into account stop words in A Modern hisappears 22 times and her appears 20 times.

SameDiff

The next tool that was explored was databasic.io’s SamDiff. In this tool, you give it two texts and it shows you the similarities and differences on a word level. The results for comparing both of the versions are shown below.

Words only in
Inkle and Yarico
Words in both Words only in A Modern Inkle and Yarico
women
arietta
story
lion
till
sex
said
person
old
observed
mind
lovers
good
ephesian
did
agreeable

See more

youth
woman
went
way
voyage
vessel
transcribed
touched
thomas
think
take
shore
ship
shew
sexes
self
safety
regard
raillery
quotations
put
piece
passions
party
particular
mr
matron
manner
make
main
loss
lions
interests
horses
honour
give
found
european
english
edition
dispute
discourse
countrymen
consider
consequently
coming
celebrated
cave
barbadoes
adventurer
achilles
account
accompanied
wrought
writings
writers
writer
world
wood

man
young
made
indians
yarico
inkle
time
perfect
men
little
indian
general
eyes

See more

years
wild
part
noble
love
limbs
language
great
feathers
fair
dress
day
taken
new
life
killed
history
hair
girl
friend
country
came
bound
away
american
works
woods
turning
thought
son
sleep
skins
shoulders
short
shells
published
play
plain
page
natural
london
light
left
island
immediately
hundred
hold
highly
hero
head
find
enamoured
collected
child
called
age

graham
white
oceola
beauty
seminole
warrior
form
charms
work
whilst
war
nature
modesty
manners
florida
felt

See more

boy
black
according
withering
uncle
tribe
tree
three
sylvan
splendor
southern
snow
simple
scarcely
rude
romantic
rifles
richest
renowned
rapture
protection
pearls
ornamented
officer
oak
niece
nathleocee
nathleocce
looking
length
laid
king
just
interspersed
hernandez
hearts
heart
graceful
fond
face
extraordinary
experienced
excitement
econchatti
destined
dance
combined
chieftain
chassee
character
blushing
americans
admiration
zephyrs
yielded
year
wounded
worth
worked

 

Immediately while looking at this data, the themes from the previous tool are apparent. For example, ignoring irrelevant words, the top shared words in both are manyoung, and indians which go with the themes of gender, youth, and colonialism mentioned earlier. What I find interesting between these two stories, however, is the tone of the words. Steele’s version is the only one that has the word sex which could mean a merely transactional interaction. Also in that version, not only does Inkle sell-off Yarico, but he also comes to regret their interactions:

“To be short, Mr. Thomas Inkle, now coming into English Territories, began seriously to reflect upon his loss of time, and to weigh with himself how many days interest of his money he had lost during his stay with Yarico.”

 

In contrast, A Modern Inkle and Yarico ends with them staying with each other and it doesn’t mention sex:

“Three successive seasons produced as many offspring to gladden the hearts of the affectionate parents; then came a withering blight upon their hopes of future happiness—the fond wife was destined to be separated by the rude hand of war from her husband, and the father from his children.”

 

The tone of the words used in the different versions of Inkle and Yarico shines a light on the tone of the pieces as a whole. Just by looking at the appearance and frequency of certain words, we can make assumptions about the piece as a whole (such as its themes).

Conclusion

By this, we can answer the question at the beginning of this post. The different outcomes of the texts stem from their portrayal of gender and race. In A Modern Inkle and Yarico, the text was more personal, focusing on their love and their relationship rather than just sex. This resulted in a positive outcome for Yarico.

Metadata

  • Length: 1477 words
  • Publication date: December 18th, 1841
  • Publication location: London
  • Perspective: Third-person, (assumed) pro abolitionist
  • Yarico’s Race: Native American
  • Outcome: Marriage
  • Theme: Gender, race, and colonialism